The Best Homemade Cracker Jack

he Best Homemade Cracker Jack - I don’t have memories of eating candy as a child but I do remember the allure of the Cracker Jack’s box.  The cute cartoon sailor boy on the front.  The neatly wrapped box holding the sweet, crunchy caramel popcorn and peanut mix AND the coveted prize inside.  Early on, before my time, prizes included decoder rings and other captivating trinkets making it a most popular treat.

The Cracker Jack’s history is a success story detailing the promise of the American dream held in the late 1800’s.  German immigrant Frederick William Rueckheim originated the recipe in 1872, developing the formula for Cracker Jack with his brother which he sold from a popcorn street cart.  Rueckheim mass produced the blend for the 1893 Chicago World’s Fair which proved to be a launching point for the snack’s future.

Salted Peanuts in the Shell - The facts about the name’s origin are foggy however one account suggests a pleased customer uttered the product to be ‘Cracker jack!’, an exuberant slang of the time for all things most excellent. The popular song ‘Take Me Out to the Ball Game’, with the signature lyric ‘buy me some peanuts and Cracker Jack’ in 1908, cemented the product’s role in American food history.

We’ve seen the product evolve through logos, flavors, and company ownership changes (all depicted in an infographic by Frito Lay, the current owner, below), marching arm and arm through 120 years of American history.  Over time the ratio of peanuts seems to have decreased, a controversial topic addressed in the press by rabid fans, some of whom have taken to actually counting the peanuts to prove their point.  Regardless of the changes the product is an undisputed success story in Americana food.

Homemade Cracker Jack -

I have developed my own spin on Cracker Jack for the home cook.  Unlike some of the other Americana foods I’ve featured in the past week I held true to my childhood memory of this product, albeit allowing an option for lighter coating if desired recognizing it IS bathing suit season.  The original product included molasses which I’ve mimicked through the use of dark corn syrup garnering the thumbs up from my taste testers as being incredibly close the original version, as well as a worthy celebration for the true American snack.

Homemade 'Cracker Jack' -


The Best Homemade Cracker Jack

Prep Time: 15 minutes

Cook Time: 45 minutes

Total Time: 1 hour, 30 minutes

Yield: 10 1/2 to 12 1/2 cups depending on how much popcorn used

A simple, delicious recipe to make America's classic snack treat, Cracker Jack, at home!


  • 10-12 cups of popped Popcorn (about ¾ cups unpopped when using a stove top popper)*
  • 1 ¼ cups Dark Brown Sugar
  • ¼ cup Dark Corn Syrup
  • 10 tablespoons unsalted Butter, cut into pieces about 1 tablespoon each
  • 1 teaspoon Kosher Salt
  • 1 cup Spanish Peanuts


  1. Preheat oven to 250 degrees. Place popcorn in a large, deep baking or roasting pan; selecting a size which will allow easy coating of the popcorn and turning it during baking without it spilling out of the pan.
  2. In a medium-large sauce pan, combine the brown sugar, corn syrup, butter and salt. Bring the mixture to a low boil, stirring constantly with a whisk to melt sugar and fully combine all ingredients. Continue to whisk mixture for 1-2 minutes following the sugar melting.
  3. Sprinkle the peanuts on the popcorn. Pour the caramel mixture over the popcorn and peanuts and turn the popcorn over in the caramel sauce to fully coat, scooping any up from the bottom of the pan onto the popcorn.
  4. Place in the preheated oven. Every 10-15 minutes, remove the pan and scoop any caramel from the bottom of the pan back into the popcorn to coat the popcorn thoroughly. Return to the oven. Continue this process 3-4 times until the popcorn has cooked for about 45 minutes.
  5. Turn popcorn out in a single layer onto parchment or wax paper and allow to cool fully.**


*for lighter coating use 12 cups popcorn; for a heavy coating use 10 cups popcorn.

**In my research I discovered mention of difficulties when making similar caramel corn in highly humid conditions. Based on this I'd suggest making this Cracker Jack on low humidity days.

Homemade Cracker Jack -

To culminate the past week of American food exploration I am holding a giveaway of two of my favorite things.  My own life evolution can be marked by popcorn makers going from Jiffy Pop and a pot on the stovetop as a child, through hot air poppers, microwave popcorn as an adult back to the best popcorn popper ever, The Whirly-Pop, manufactured in the U.S. and producing the most lofty popcorn without burning on the stovetop.   Winner may select classic silver or new addition red!

Whirly Pop silver |

I’ve also learned that popcorn does taste differently if buying a quality brand.  My favorite is a local Farmer’s Market discovery in Boulder from Boulder Popcorn.  I made my Cracker Jack using three varieties they sell which ironically are close to red, white and blue in color.  I’m including a bag of Boulder Popcorn’s ‘Mayor’s Blend’ which uses the three varieties I did in this recipe.

This is not a sponsored giveaway but rather my own personal gift in celebration of our nation’s birthday!

To enter the Giveaway (open to U.S. residents/shipping addresses only):    {CLOSED}

  1. Leave a comment saying ‘Pop, Pop, Pop!’

For additional entries (please leave a separate comment for each entry verifying what you have done; if you are already doing any of these, leave a separate comment for each one stating that):

  1. For following BoulderLocavore on Pinterest.
  2. For following Boulder Locavore on Facebook.
  3. Subscribe to Boulder Locavore via email (note: once subscribing be sure to ‘verify’ your request by typing in the code on the verification email you’ll be sent! If unverified this entry will not count).
  4. Tweet about the Giveaway including a link to this post and @BoulderLocavore for entry tracking. 
  5. Post on Facebook about this Giveaway including a link to this post and @BoulderLocavore  for entry tracking.


Total of 6 possible entries!!!

No purchase required. Void where prohibited by law. Must be 18 or older to enter.


THE WINNER IS:  MEREDITH!  Congratulations!

Giveaway will run through midnight Monday, July 8 at which time a winner will be selected using and posted here on Tuesday July 9th.

Cracker Jack Infographic


  1. Cindy G. says

    I’m not entering the giveaway, I just have a question… You said you used dark corn syrup instead of molasses. I happen to have some molasses on hand (but no dark corn syrup), so I was wondering if I could make the substitution?

  2. Liz says

    Pop Pop Pop. Thank you. I do subscribe by email. Thanks for your offering. Love popcorn and cracker jacks.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *