Rich, creamy Tapioca Pudding is a classic dessert recipe everyone loves. Its whimsical texture and creamy custard never go out of style.
This is that tapioca pudding your mom….or grandmother used to make.
Sure, you can buy it premade at the store. But one bite of the homemade version will remind you why it has always been a favorite.
Once you make it you’ll see why. It’s creamy, rich, comforting.
Luscious Tapioca Recipe
Sometimes it’s just nice to do things the old fashioned way. And one bite will let you know why.
There’s just something about the creamy vanilla-flavored pudding with the tiny tapioca orbs that keep generation after generation making and loving it.
You can eat it warm or cold.
Eat it as is or load it up with toppings (check our ‘Variations’ section below for ideas).
Recipe Ingredients + Notes
Tapioca. Use ‘small pearl tapioca’ (it will be noted on the package) and do not use Instant Tapioca.
You’ll find tapioca pearls with the baking supplies. They are naturally gluten-free too.
Be sure NOT to use the large pearl tapioca used for making Boba or milk tea. We used it for this Spider Egg Pudding but it’s not the right type for classic tapioca pudding.
Milk. We recommend whole milk for the best results.
Salt. Use kosher salt if possible. It’s a less salty flavored salt.
Eggs. You’ll need two.
Granulated sugar. This gives the tapioca pudding just the right amount of sweetness. You’ll need 1/2 cup.
Vanilla extract. Gives a homey flavor.
Variations
Coconut tapioca. Instead of dairy milk use coconut milk for a light coconut flavor.
Use less sugar. If you’d like to lighted up the sugar it can be reduced to 1/3 cup. In our tested we felt 1/2 cup was ‘just right’ but it’s still sweet with 1/3 cup too.
Use one egg. The eggs give richness but it can be reduced to one egg if desired.
Use some cream. For an even richer pudding, replace some of the milk with cream. Still use a total of 3 cups of milk or milk plus cream.
Topping ideas. Sprinkle on some cinnamon or nutmeg. Add a dollop of whipped cream. Add some sliced berries or bananas.
Do tapioca pearls need to be soaked first?
Read the instructions on the package of tapioca pearls you use regarding soaking.
Some versions require soaking first. For time saving we used a version that did not require soaking.
If using a soaked tapioca decrease the milk to 2 1/2 cups. Monitor the cooking time too as it may be faster.
Sample the pudding when it is done to determine if the pearls are softened and cooked.
What is tempering eggs?
One of the most important steps in making any custard with eggs is ‘tempering’ the eggs.
This is a method of adding just a bit of hot liquid to the eggs and whisking it in to gently warm the eggs.
The eggs are then added to the hot liquid and whisked to ensure the eggs don’t scramble when added.
If eggs are added directly to the heated milk they would scramble and not integrate to make the rich, creamy custard.
How to Make it – Step-by-Step
STEP 1. Heat the tapioca mixture
Combine the milk, tapioca pearls, sugar and salt in a heavy, medium saucepan over medium heat (photo 1).
Stir often until the mixture is foamy on top and almost simmering.
Reduce heat to low.
Cook until the tapioca pearls are translucent and plump; 20-35 minutes.
STEP 2. Mix eggs and vanilla extract
Combine the eggs and vanilla extract in a mixing bowl; whisk (photo 2).
STEP 3. Temper the eggs
Add a few large spoonfuls of the hot tapioca mixture into the egg mixture.
Whisk constantly to mix together and prevent the eggs from scrambling (photo 3).
Slowly return the mixture to the saucepan (photo 4). and whisk constantly to mix in.
STEP 4. Finish the tapioca
Increase the heat to medium and stir constantly until the tapioca thickens (photo 5); approximately 5 minutes.
Remove from heat and cool for 20 minutes before serving (it will continue to thicken).
Pro Tips
Set plastic wrap on the surface of the pudding while it cools. This is a trick used for making curd recipes too.
It prevents a skin from developing on the top of the pudding!
Tapioca thickens as it cools. If the pudding doesn’t look completely thickened when the cooking ends don’t worry! It will continue to thicken as it cools.
FAQs
Those are tapioca pearls which come from a starch harvested from cassava root. The pearls only add texture. On their own they don’t have much flavor. The flavor comes from the pudding ingredients.
Yes! Try this slow cooker almond milk tapioca version. Coconut milk can be used too.
Storing Leftovers
Allow the pudding to fully cool. Place in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 1 week.
More Recipes You’ll Love!
