Peanut Butter French Toast and Homemade Organic Strawberry Syrup

When I was growing up I was obsessed with peanut butter.  I felt it went with everything and spared no other food from an experimental addition of some ‘PB’ at one time or another.  I even would sometimes sneak out of bed and scoop out a handful of it to eat plain (which now sadly sounds more like a closet eating disorder rather than an unbridled childhood culinary fixation).
As kids my Mom would always let us pick what we wanted on our birthdays for breakfast.  My choice was always Peanut Butter French Toast.  I’m not sure where the original recipe came from; whether my Mom made it up to appease my enthusiastic food crush or whether she found it somewhere.
I’d forgotten about Peanut Butter French Toast as I’ve not had it as an adult, however last week was my birthday and for some reason it sprang to mind.  I decided it was the perfect time to create a current recipe to bring my childhood memory out of mothballs into the present.  It also meshed with what I really wanted to do for my birthday which was go strawberry picking at a favorite local organic farm.  I thought making some Homemade Organic Strawberry Syrup would be a great match.
For me a signature summer food experience is berry picking.  My favorite location is Berry Patch Farms in Brighton Colorado.  It is an organic farm and a mix between ‘you pick’ and farm-harvested produce that is available for sale in their barn store on site. 
Colorado has two strawberry picking seasons; a short one in June and the longer season in August.  We’ve had unseasonal early heat which brought on the June strawberries early as well.  Things worked out that the first possible day to go would be my birthday and ironically I received an email from the farm the night before saying that would also be the last picking day of the June season!  Seemed like destiny.
On a blustery, hot, relatively crowded day my kids and I spent about 40 minutes searching through the fields for 4 beautiful, perfectly ripened quarts of organic strawberries for which we paid $13 (actually there were a few juice boxes in there too so it would have been less)!  I have mentioned this before but the flavor of a field ripened strawberry tastes nothing like a store purchased strawberries.  They are completely sweet in a much fuller, more flavorful way and soft in texture.  It’s really ruined me for purchasing strawberries in a store but there could be a worse fate.  If you have a chance to purchase berries freshly picked from a farm or picked yourself, you must do it!
As you might guess this Peanut Butter French toast and Strawberry Syrup combo tastes just like a PBJ sandwich in the best way.  With minimal sweetening the natural flavors of both the peanuts and the strawberries shine through.  Still a peanut butter lover, I love the warm peanut flavor and felt it makes for a unique, satisfying dish.  It was devoured by my familial taste testers.  Even the one not as partial to peanut butter begged me to make it for breakfast the following day.
A note on French toast bread choices.  Traditional thinking is that French toast is a perfect use of stale bread as it tends to soak up the egg mixture more.  I have followed that and also made French toast with regular bread and find both are good.  I bake my own gluten free bread (Gluten Free Pantry ‘Favorite Sandwich Bread’  augmented with chia seeds and other seeds for additional protein and fiber) so I used that with great results.  A favorite French toast bread for me prior to becoming gluten free was croissants.  If you have not made French toast with croissants you must try it!
Yield:  1 serving of 2 pieces of toast
·         ½ tablespoon butter
·         1 egg
·         1 teaspoon agave nectar
·         2 tablespoons milk
·         2 tablespoons peanut butter, room temperature ; smooth or crunchy, your preference
·         2 slices of bread (gluten free or gluten bread)


1.       Heat a small skillet to medium-high and melt butter.
2.      In a small bowl whisk together egg, agave, milk and peanut butter until fully combined.
3.      Pour mixture into a deep dish, flat bottom bowl or a pie tin.  Dip each side of bread into the batter fully coating it.
4.      Place coated bread into the hot skillet and allow to brown on each side; about a minute per side (check by lifting toast with a spatula).  When browned on both sides, remove from skillet and serve with powdered sugar and Homemade Organic Strawberry Syrup.
The strawberries I used were very sweet and very soft.  If you taste your berries and they are not as sweet you can always add more sweetener to your syrup.  I like honey though different varieties can have distinct flavors so always taste it for your liking first.  Also granulated sugar helps preserve the color of the berries in a way honey does not which is another reason I used it.  If your berries are harder, you may chop them into very small pieces before attempting to mash them which will help.
Yield:  1 ¾ cups syrup
·         1 quart strawberries (I prefer organic)
·         ¼ cup honey
·         ¼ cup granulated sugar
·         ½ cup water
·         1 teaspoon arrowroot starch (or cornstarch)
1.       Hull, core and slice strawberries.  Place them in a heavy saucepan and mash with potato masher or back of a large spoon.
2.      In a small bowl, mix arrowroot starch in the ½ cup water with a whisk to fully combine.  Add sugar and honey.  Stir to mix together and pour over strawberries in the saucepan.
3.      Bring to a medium boil and immediately reduce heat to medium or medium-low, allowing mixture to just simmer for 20-25 minutes when it should be thicker.  Much of the thickening happens after it sits so don’t worry if it is not syrup consistency entirely.  Consistency note: if the syrup is more chunky that you desire, you may use a immersion or stick blender at this stage to smooth out the consistency.
4.      Remove mixture from heat and allow it to cool for 20 minutes.  Use on French toast, pancakes, waffles or anything else you desire.  Place any access in a sealed jar in the refrigerator for up to 2 weeks.


  1. says

    I've never thought of peanut butter french toast, what a great idea! Certainly much better than the tired out version Banana French toast! Your syrup looks like a perfect compliment, what could be better than a BB&J served french toast style!

    • says

      You know how you grow up with a food not thinking about it? I assumed everyone ate PB French toast! Would this be a good time to confess my favorite sandwich was Peanut Butter and banana with mayo? Maybe I've over shared now…

    • says

      That's a great idea Angie! I was completely focused on this dish so did not think outside the breakfast box about other meal options. Because the syrup is not madly sweet, it would compliment the dessert rather than compete with it too I think. Thanks for reading and taking the time to comment!

  2. says

    I've never thought of this either, and when I clicked on the link, I wasn't sure what to expect, but it looks so good. It might even be a great dessert with the sweet syrup!

    • says

      I realize the image this title might conjure could be scary! This is really delicious and well balanced. For me the whole sugar aspect can really overwhelm this type of dish but in this case it takes a back seat. I DO think putting this syrup on a dessert is a great one!

  3. says

    Your strawberry syrup looks amazing! I can almost smell the strawberries! I'm hoping there will be lots of strawberries in my future this summer! x

  4. says

    I love strawberry season. So much! And this recipe totally reminds me of my childhood. I lived on french toast! But I can honestly say I've never had french toast that looks this good. Absolutely stunning.

    • says

      Thanks Lindsay! As I mentioned this completely dropped off my rader for a number of years and sprang from nowhere last week. I was glad to try it again more to my current way of eating. It is delicious and I loved the way the syrup turned out! Hope the new job is going well!

  5. says

    Well goodness, doesn't peanut butter French toast with homemade strawberry syrup sound good! And Happy Birthday Toni. If I didn't have a full time job, I'd be a regular at Berry Patch.

    • says

      Thank you Lea Ann! It was a good birthday and this was a delicious outcome. I think it will be a funny year for picking this year; being a drought year and so hot. We'll see!

  6. says

    Terrific idea! I've never heard of this, but it's kind of like a peanut butter and jelly sandwich on steroids! Really interesting flavors. Wonderful post – thanks.

    • says

      It kinda IS like a PBJ on steroids, you're right! It's funny growing up loving this I assume everyone else ate it too. I'm realizing after publishing this such is not the case. Now is the chance to try it!

      Thanks for taking the time to read and comment.

  7. says

    I love making food from my childhood and although my mom did not make peanut butter french toast, I sure wish she did! So tell me, what gluten-free bread do you recommend? Every brand that I have tried from Whole Foods is like a brick. BTW, we just bought a bunch of different gluten free beers this weekend and we are going to invite some friends over for a blind taste test. Thanks for the recommendations!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *